76

Re: Reasoning for leaving GNU/Linux: Definitely needed!

Let's talk short but direct about Steam (and other so-called platforms offering software-entertainment): Within a newly released claim it is now clear to see that people only give money for "the right to use software within given rules companies and the platform itself are able to change at will". So in fact: People are renting software, not even buying any license. And this is not the only platform: Battle.net, UPlay and so many more acting the same way. No right to "own a license" but only to pay for using until others forbid this. And the best aside: People around GNU/Linux telling that Steam has brought so much and Valve did so much. Yes? Please, tell more fairy-tales. Valve is only doing this for their own purpose. To own the people, enforcing them staying on the platform. Same as others have done later on also with other named platforms. We do not "own" software, we do not even "own" a license for usage. We just pay for renting something, not even a right to use. Just paying that amount others tell us doing so.

And what about the software? Well, when the owning persons and institutions decide the software should be no longer of usage, they just cut off people using it as they do not "own" a license, just the current "right to use" - with the option to loose this at any given time. And then the software itself is forgotten as of no longer usage for earning money. A brave new world!

Human being in favor with clear principles and so also for freedom in soft- and hardware!

Certainly anyone who has the power to make you believe absurdities has the power to make you commit injustices: For a life of every being full with peace and kindness, including diversity and freedom. Capitalism is destroying our minds, the planet itself and the universe in the end!

77

Re: Reasoning for leaving GNU/Linux: Definitely needed!

Linux it's just a kernel, any other libre *nix kernel (Hurd, HBSD) it's more than enough to run GNU software.  Also, bloating up the kernel instead of having a good design from the core it's a bad way to create a frankenmess in order to please corporations. Hurd looks better with the  services on top of a microkernel, a bad driver can't hang the OS and the users can mount drivers and remote shares on userspace and with no privileged rights.  GNU's isn't just about cloning Unix, it's about going further and enhancing it.

78

Re: Reasoning for leaving GNU/Linux: Definitely needed!

GNU is failing its mission-statement nevertheless: Going further and enhancing it ... is a bad joke and not working. Let's look where this has gone: Acceptance and inclusion of more bloated frameworks, partwise even making them mandatory and it gets harder and harder to remove those like systemd-inclusion from version to version. There is in fact no need to use buzzwords besides that GNU Hurd is not finalized in all parts. Yes, it is possible to build dreamcastles but GNU as said is failing as there are enough projects not even calling it GNU/Linux. So repeating that sentence does not hit the point (Linux is only the kernel). Free software is not even used often to be called. Too many people use wrong phrases and that is also based on the pragmatic choices GNU has done and ignorance has been driven from within the GNU-project. In fact the so-called enhancement is just a nice phrase, nothing more.

Or GNU Hurd for example taking part at "Google Summer of Code", another questionable and pragmatic choice. But yeah, in a way somewhat open and whatever kind of free. So free, that users do not really support and the way GNU Hurd gets support is also not really seen from within the community but than Google coming into. Interesting choices, yes ... and the latest stable release is from 2016 with version 0.9. So to underline: That is not working and failure. The FSF is not even really supporting the original kernel mean for a GNU-system therefore. But well, exactly out of that reasoning Hyperbola has NO interest in this. We package and include working, efficient and small oriented parts of GNU-applications. The rest is kept outside and therefore Hyperbola has also no generic interest to work further with or into this. We just call our system HyperbolaBSD out of the reasoning and this is NOT just the kernel but a complete BSD-descendant operating-system. There won't be a GNU-system with HyperBK kernel. This is not the way this was announced and not the way the project is oriented. If others want to use the HyperBK-kernel for a GNU-based system? Their choice as it is free and libre software. But as said: Not here in the context of HyperbolaBSD. HyperbolaBSD will be a non-GNU system! And there is no real other system around besides GNU/Linux as GNU/Hurd is not really there beyond Debian done. And that as said is another illusion: "Linux is just the kernel!" ... yes, but without it GNU never would be  possible then and now. That's part of the story!

Hyperbola GNU/Linux-libre is called that way as we include the glibc and GNU/Linux-libre. Hyperbola itself will leave this for sure as HyperbolaBSD is not using glibc and also not GNU/Linux-libre. So this thread is about the reasonings and to make exactly those misunderstanding clear. Again: HyperbolaBSD is HyperbolaBSD and a complete own project with using parts of some GNU-applications we see fitting. The rest is NOT GNU and will stay also that. Repeating the wishful thought that GNU would be different and make it different sounds nice, but does not hit this project and also not the current reality. And no, we are NOT "just the kernel" as this is failing the description of our project. Besides that "Linux is just the / a kernel": Undercomplex answers to complex questions have never really helped anyone and solved nothing. But we can surely repeat that, just this does not get more near the reality then. smile

Human being in favor with clear principles and so also for freedom in soft- and hardware!

Certainly anyone who has the power to make you believe absurdities has the power to make you commit injustices: For a life of every being full with peace and kindness, including diversity and freedom. Capitalism is destroying our minds, the planet itself and the universe in the end!